A Florida couple who sued a fertility clinic after giving birth to a baby genetically unrelated to them confirmed they have identified their daughter’s biological parents through DNA testing. The discovery marks a turning point in a case that raises profound questions about medical oversight and the fate of their own missing embryos.
Clinic Error Led to Wrong Embryo Implant
Tiffany Score and Steven Mills filed a lawsuit in January against Fertility Center of Orlando and Dr. Milton McNichol, alleging another patient’s embryo was implanted in Score’s uterus in April 2025. The couple, both Caucasian, gave birth to their now four-month-old daughter Shea, who they recognized immediately was not biologically related to them based on her physical appearance. Genetic testing confirmed the child shares no DNA with either parent.
The couple stored three viable embryos at the Longwood clinic in 2020 for in vitro fertilization. Their lawsuit states they developed an intense emotional bond with their daughter during pregnancy and wish to keep her, but acknowledge she should be united with her genetic parents if they are fit and willing. Attorney Jack Scarola confirmed Shea’s biological parents have not requested custody.
Missing Embryos Remain Mystery
Score and Mills stated that questions about their own embryos remain unanswered and may never be resolved. The couple fears another woman could have been impregnated with their biological child, creating a heartbreaking scenario where families unknowingly raise children not genetically related to them. Their attorney indicated the legal proceeding will address these unresolved matters while pursuing compensation for expenses and severe emotional trauma.
Clinic Announces Closure
The Fertility Clinic of Orlando announced earlier this month it would close by May 20 following what leadership described as thoughtful consideration. The closure comes as the lawsuit proceeds and raises concerns about accountability and record preservation. Score and Mills pledged to respect the privacy of Shea’s biological parents and keep their identities confidential, emphasizing their commitment to loving and raising the child regardless of genetics. The case highlights potential vulnerabilities in fertility clinic protocols that impact families pursuing pregnancy through assisted reproduction.
